Community Science InstituteCommunity Science InstituteCommunity Science InstituteCommunity Science Institute
  • No Menu Set

Red Flag Volunteers Collect Reliable Data

    Home "Red Flag" Monitoring Red Flag Volunteers Collect Reliable Data
    NextPrevious

    Red Flag Volunteers Collect Reliable Data

    By abnerx | "Red Flag" Monitoring, News | Comments are Closed | 20 January, 2015 | 0

    When one thinks of scientific data collection, volunteers working in the field with test kits and clipboards may not be the first image that comes to mind.  With any volunteer stream monitoring program ensuring that accurate, reliable data is being collected is essential to a successful program. Unlike CSI’s flagship Synoptic Sampling program, where samples are tested in the certified lab, Red Flag volunteers take on the testing themselves in the field.

    So how can we rely on volunteers to collect good data? It starts with intensive training workshops, totaling 8 hours, where volunteers gain hands-on practice at collecting and testing samples with instruction from CSI. In absence of clear guidelines from regulatory agencies about what types of quality control must be performed by volunteers, CSI applies its certified lab criteria to volunteers in the field. Just like in our lab, volunteers begin their testing by calibrating equipment with known standard solutions – identical to the solutions used in the lab. For every assay performed, like total hardness, the certified lab is required to perform a duplicate test on at least 5% of samples, and the results must be within a close range. That means testing the same sample twice – and you should get the same result twice. Volunteers perform duplicates for every test parameter on one of their samples each time they monitor. Then there’s the split samples. Four times per year, volunteers send in a sample to the CSI lab, where it is tested for conductivity and total hardness, two of the tests volunteers perform in the field. Lab results are compared to volunteer results – and agree more than 90% of the time.

    SRBC SondeIt’s fair to say that CSI’s internal quality control of volunteer data is strict. Similar to the split samples, another method of evaluating volunteer data is by comparing it to other data that already exists from a reliable source. Red Flag volunteers monitor several of the same streams as the Susquehanna River Basin Commission (SRBC). In response to the need for not only baseline data, but also for real-time water quality data in areas of shale gas development, the SRBC established its Remote Water Quality Monitoring Network at 58 locations in Pennsylvania and New York streams. These sondes (robotic monitoring devices) collect water quality data every five minutes and upload data to the SRBC website every two hours. SRBC sondes measure five parameters: temperature, pH, dissolved oxygen, conductivity, and turbidity. Red Flag volunteers also monitor five parameters, but test for total hardness and not turbidity.

    The SRBC’s remote network is primarily in Pennsylvania, where shale gas development using hydrofracking has been taking place for the last few years. Eleven sondes are in New York state, and five are in watersheds where Red Flag volunteers are collecting data. Sondes are typically placed near the mouth of a stream, whereas Red Flag monitoring locations are typically situated at multiple locations throughout a watershed, including the mouth.

    To compare the data, CSI Intern Kristen Carr identified the CSI monitoring location closest to the SRBC sonde in that watershed. Then, volunteer data was downloaded using the “Search Streams and Lakes” page of the CSI Database. Using the SRBC website , data from the dates that Red Flag volunteers monitored were downloaded. Data from the two sources were compared using MS Excel and the results are promising.

    For each of the four parameters, volunteer data and SRBC data followed the same patterns over time. Two creeks are shown here – Catatonk Creek and Baldwin Creek. Some variation is to be expected due to differences in equipment and exact time of measurement. The overall comparison shows that Red Flag volunteers are capable of producing data that are similar to government agency data. Combined with the extensive internal quality control, Red Flag volunteers collect data that can be relied on.

    Catatonk Conductivity comparisonbaldwin creek conductivity

    Share
    No tags.

    NextPrevious

    Connect with Us

    The Community Science Institute
    Langmuir Lab Building/ Box 1044
    95 Brown Rd.
    Ithaca, NY 14850

    (607) 257-6606

    info@communityscience.org

    Support Our Work

    Donate

    Recent Posts

    • Why we volunteer as HAB Harriers

      Please enjoy this article written by one of CSI’s longterm HABs Harriers,

      18 August, 2025
    • Save the Date: “HAB-by Hour” at Cayuga Shoreline

      13 May, 2025
    Copyright 2007-2016 Community Science Institute | Developed by: Abner X. Figueroa
    • About Us
      • Alyssa Johnson
    • Adrianna Hirtler
    • Aleah Young
    • Annual Reports
    • Baseline Testing
    • Bill George
    • Biological Monitoring
    • Biological Monitoring Results
    • Bloom Form
    • Calendar
    • Cayuga Lake 2018 Harmful Algal Blooms Results
    • Cayuga Lake 2019 Harmful Algal Bloom Results
    • Certified Water Testing
      • Non-Potable Water Tests & Fees
      • Potable and Non-Potable Water Tests & Fees
    • Contact Us
    • CSI Data Updates
    • CSI News Archive
    • CSI-Volunteer Database
      • Database Home
      • Pre-Fracking Groundwater Baselines
        • Select and Download Groundwater Baselines
      • Streams and Lakes Data
        • Cayuga Lake Region
        • Select and Download Streams and Lakes Data
        • Seneca Lake Region
        • Upper Susquehanna River Region
    • CSI’s Business Membership Program
    • Dan Pascucci
    • Drinking Water Resources for the General Public
    • Employment Opportunities
    • FAQ – Testers!
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Get Involved
    • Glossary
    • Grascen Shidemantle
    • Home
    • Homepage
    • I want to test my water
      • Glossary
    • Journey of Water
      • Young Scientists
    • Kathryn Graham
    • Katia Appel
    • Logout
    • Lost Password
    • Maps
    • Meet Our Board of Directors
    • Meet Our Staff
    • Membership Form
    • Monitoring Partnerships
      • Biological Monitoring
        • BMI Results
      • Harmful Algal Bloom Monitoring on Cayuga Lake
        • Harmful Algal Bloom Datasets
      • Owego Creek Tributaries Monitoring Project with Trout Unlimited
      • Past CSI Monitoring Programs
      • Red Flag Monitoring
        • Red Flag Monitoring Symposium
      • Synoptic Sampling
    • Noah Mark
    • Outreach and Education
      • CSI News and Monthly Updates
      • Learning Materials
      • Press
      • Public Events and Presentations
        • Drinking Water Wednesdays
        • HABs Forum
      • Publications
      • The Water Bulletin Newsletter
    • Rama Hoetzlein
    • Report a HAB
    • Resources
      • Water Quality Resources
      • What’s In Your Watershed? Series
    • Resources
    • Seth Bingham
    • Stephen Penningroth
    • Test Events Page
    • Volunteer With Us!
    • Water Testing Payments
    • Reports
    • Gas Well “Signature Chemicals”
      • Baseline Testing
        • FAQ – Baseline Testing
      • Regional Baseline Initiative
    • Volunteer Partners
      • Funding
    • Donate
      • 2025-2026 Business Membership Partners
    • Blog Medium View
    • database.communityscience.org
    • Message Box
    • Icon
    • Code
    • Qoute
    • Testimonials
    • Team
    • Divider
    • List
    • sliders
    • Font awesome icons
    • Password Protected
    • Gallery
      • Gallery 4 Column
      • Gallery 3 Column
      • Gallery 2 Column
      • Gallery Masnory View
    • Events
      • Events With Filterable
      • Events Right Sidebar
    • Blog
      • Blog Right Sidebar
    • Highlight
    • Dropcap
    • Map
    • Tables
    • Tabs
    • Accordion & Toggle
    • Buttons
    • Images
    • Video
    • Typography
    • Columns
    • Home
    • Services
    • Contact Us
    Community Science Institute
    X